Your Cart


You have no items in your cart.

Shop our collections
Free Shipping On Orders $90+ Icon
Free Returns Icon
30 Day Trial Icon
  • Free Shipping

    On Orders $90+
  • Free Returns

  • 30-Day Trial

  • Wellness

    How To Clean Cookie and Baking Sheets: 6 Pro Tips

    Baking Sheet Duo - Cookies - Header - Navy - Lifestyle

    At Caraway, we know that a clean baking sheet is the secret to successful baking and cooking. Yet, even the most seasoned bakers struggle with stubborn stains and baked-on residue.

    Why does this happen? Because everything from roasting vegetables to baking cookies can leave a tough mess that challenges even the most diligent cleaners.

    Our guide is here to help you tackle these challenges head-on, ensuring your baking sheets are as spotless as they are functional.

    Why Is It Important To Keep Your Baking Sheets Clean?

    Maintaining clean cookie and baking sheets isn't just about aesthetics---it significantly impacts your cooking results and the longevity of your bakeware.

    Here's why keeping these kitchen workhorses pristine is crucial:

    Enhanced Cooking Performance

    Clean baking sheets distribute heat more evenly. This uniform heat distribution is essential for achieving perfectly browned cookies and evenly cooked meals. Residue and buildup can create hot spots that cause uneven baking, leading to some areas that are undercooked and others burnt.

    Extended Bakeware Lifespan

    Regular cleaning prevents the accumulation of oils and food particles that can corrode and degrade the material of your baking sheets over time. By keeping them clean, you avoid premature wear and tear, ensuring that your bakeware remains functional for a longer period.

    Food Safety

    Old food residue on baking sheets can harbor bacteria and other pathogens, posing health risks. Clean sheets minimize the risk of foodborne illnesses, keeping your kitchen safe.

    Improved Flavor

    Leftover grease and burnt food can impact the flavors of anything you bake next. Clean baking sheets ensure that the tastes of your baked goods remain untainted and delightful, true to your recipes.

    Easier Usage and Storage

    Clean bakeware is simply easier to handle and store. It won't transfer old grease, crumbs, or odors to other items in your kitchen, maintaining the overall hygiene and organization of your cooking space.

    Large Baking Sheet - Gray - Veggies on Sheet

    What Makes Cookie and Baking Sheets Hard To Clean?

    Now that you understand the importance of keeping your baking sheets in tip-top shape, it's worth exploring why they often present such a challenge to clean. Cookie and baking sheets are subjected to a variety of baking and cooking scenarios that can leave them less than spotless, making thorough cleaning a necessity but often a hassle.

    Here's what contributes to the difficulty:

    • High Baking Temperatures: Baking and roasting typically require high temperatures, which can cause food residues like oils and fats to bake onto the surface, creating a hard-to-remove caramelized layer.

    • Sugary and Starchy Foods: Sugars and starches are particularly prone to sticking and can burn onto the pan at high temperatures. Once caramelized, these residues are hard to scrub off and can become a recurring nuisance, affecting the taste and appearance of future bakes.

    • Irregular Cleaning Practices: The longer food residue sits on the sheets, the harder it becomes to remove. Frequent use without regular cleaning allows layers of grease and food particles to build up, compounding the problem with every use.

    • Material and Surface Condition: The material of the baking sheet affects how baked-on residues behave. For example, uncoated sheets can experience more sticking and staining than non-stick surfaces, which can degrade over time if not properly maintained.

    • Chemical Reactions: Certain foods can cause chemical reactions with the material of the baking sheet, leading to discoloration and permanent stains that are difficult to remove and can affect the performance of the bakeware.

    Understanding these challenges is the first step in adopting the right strategies to effectively clean your baking sheets, ensuring they remain a valuable asset in your kitchen arsenal.

    Pro Tips for Cleaning Cookie and Baking Sheets

    Ready to tackle those stubborn stains on your baking sheets? Here are six effective tips to ensure your cookie and baking sheets remain as functional and pristine as they are meant to be:

    1. Soak To Loosen Grime

    Before scrubbing, soak your baking sheets in hot, soapy water. This helps loosen up any stubborn, baked-on food. For sheets with heavy residue, adding a drop of dish soap directly to the problem areas before soaking can boost the cleaning power.

    2. Baking Soda and Hydrogen Peroxide Paste

    For those especially tough stains, mix baking soda with a small amount of hydrogen peroxide to form a paste. Spread this mixture across the stained areas of the baking sheet and let it sit for a couple of hours or overnight. The paste will help lift the grime, making it easier to scrub away.

    3. Soft Brush Scrubbing

    Use a soft-bristled brush or a nylon scrubbing pad with soapy water to gently scrub the baking sheet. This method is effective and avoids scratching the surface, which can happen with more abrasive materials.

    4. Lemon and Salt for Natural Cleaning

    Sprinkle salt over the baking sheet, then use a halved lemon to scrub the surface. The acid from the lemon combined with the abrasiveness of the salt is effective in breaking down baked-on residues, leaving your sheets clean and fresh.

    5. White Vinegar Rinse

    After scrubbing, rinse your baking sheets with white vinegar. This helps to dissolve any remaining alkaline baking soda residue and can help naturally disinfect the surface.

    6. Dry Thoroughly

    Post-cleaning, ensure your baking sheets are thoroughly dried to prevent rust---especially if they are made of materials prone to oxidizing. This also helps avoid water spots. 

    Medium Baking Sheet - Sage - Granola

    When Should I Replace My Cookie and Baking Sheets?

    Recognizing when to replace your cookie and baking sheets is as important as knowing how to clean them. Even the most durable bakeware has its limits.

    Here are clear signs it might be time to invest in new sheets:

    • Visible Wear and Tear: If your baking sheets show significant warping or dents or the surface has started to buckle, these physical changes can affect cooking performance, leading to uneven baking.

    • Non-Stick Surface Deterioration: For non-stick baking sheets, once the surface starts peeling or you notice that foods start sticking despite proper greasing, it's a clear indicator the non-stick coating has worn out.

    • Persistent Stains and Odors: Some stains and odors refuse to go away, no matter how much you scrub. This can affect the taste of your food and suggests the surface may be breaking down at a micro-level.

    • Rust Formation: Any signs of rust significantly compromise the integrity of the baking sheet and pose potential health risks, marking a definite time for replacement.

    When these signs start appearing, consider upgrading to Caraway's baking sheets. Our sheets not only promise a non-toxic, non-stick surface free from harmful chemicals like PTFE, PFOA, and PFAS, but they also ensure even heat distribution and easy cleanup.

    Opting for Caraway means choosing bakeware that enhances the healthfulness and flavor of your culinary creations, backed by our commitment to sustainability and quality.

    Medium Baking Sheet - Perracotta - Veggies on Sheet

    Frequently Asked Questions About Cleaning Cookie and Baking Sheets

    Still have questions? We've got you covered:

    Can I use bleach to remove tough stains from my baking sheets?

    No, avoid using bleach, as it can react with the metal and damage the surface of your baking sheets. Instead, opt for gentler home remedies like baking soda or vinegar.

    How often should I deep clean my baking sheets?

    Deep cleaning frequency depends on usage, but aiming for a thorough clean every four to six weeks can prevent buildup and maintain sheet quality.

    Are there any materials I should avoid using as scrubbers?

    Yes, avoid steel wool or metal scrubbers that can scratch the surface of your baking sheets. Instead, use nylon brushes or soft sponges.

    Can I use oven cleaner on my cookie sheets?

    It's best to avoid harsh chemicals like oven cleaners, especially on non-stick surfaces, as they can degrade the coating.

    Is it safe to clean my baking sheets in the dishwasher?

    While it might be tempting, hand washing is recommended, especially for non-stick and aluminum sheets, to avoid the harsh environment of a dishwasher, which can damage them over time.

    What's the best way to maintain my cookie and baking sheets?

    For optimal maintenance of your cookie and baking sheets, use proper utensils such as our 14-piece knife & utensil set. This Prep Set is crafted from FSC-certified birch wood and German stainless steel, featuring BPA-free handles, making it the perfect non-toxic and eco-friendly choice for protecting your bakeware during use.


    At Caraway, we understand your bakeware is an investment in your culinary adventures. Keeping your cookie and baking sheets pristine ensures delicious outcomes and extends the life of your bakeware. Remember, proper maintenance and timely replacements are key to keeping your kitchen functional and baking flawless.

    Upgrade to Caraway's baking sheets for a non-toxic, high-performance baking experience every time. Let us help make every meal a celebration of taste and health --- right from your own oven.


    How to clean and care for your sheet pans | The Washington Post

    A Clean, Safe, Healthy Kitchen & Home: The Importance of Keeping Your Kitchen Clean and Safe | Home & Garden Information Center

    How to Clean a Burnt Pot (and Salvage Your Cookware) | Martha Stewart

    What to Clean and What Not to Clean With Lemon | Consumer Reports

    Featured Stories

    Caraway Logo Text


    CookwareStainless SteelSquarewareBakewareFood StoragePrepwareTea KettleLinensGift CardSend a GiftAdd To Your Registry

    One step closer to cleaner cooking

    Unlock free shipping on your next order $90+ and be the first to learn about new collections when you sign up for emails from Caraway.

    Latest Blog Articles

    © 2024 Caraway®


    *Free shipping on orders $90+ applies to locations within the contiguous U.S., and excludes Hawaii, Alaska, and destinations outside of the U.S.

    Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions.